All posts in Marketing

Sad but predictable: The demise of HMV

3353936487_19e9efd8ce_o

Tight aisles. Stacks of DVDs and CDs. Permanent discounts. When I think of HMV, this is what comes to mind. It is a retail experience I dread as an adult. As a teenage I loved it though, we would go in between lectures and browse the newly released singles that we’d heard on Radio 1.

Sadly the world moved on. Supermarkets begain stocking the latest releases and were able to undercut on price. iPods and iTunes made ot easier to access and purchase music track by track. Spotify (Music as a Service) provided free access to nearly every track ever recorded. Just as the traditional music store was on the ropes, the death blow came with Video as a Service (Lovefilm, Netflix, iTunes and so on).

HMV and music stores in general became irrelevant.

Whilst more could have been done with multichannel or digital. The essential and missing part of the marketing mix was relevance. Why would a customer buy from HMV? Would you make them look cool like Apple? Would you make it super easy to buy like Amazon? Would you make it cheaper than anywhere else like a pound store? Would you make it experiential like Disney? Or would you offer an exclusive product that could not be obtained anywhere else?

Unfortunately for HMV they can’t compete on price effectively against the global buying power of Apple or Amazon. Also HMV’s cost base of big stores in prime retail space wouldn’t compete against purely online retailers. Transacting in a retail environment is never going to be as simple as an online transaction where the product is shipped digitally directly into my phone’s music or video library.

This leaves two routes, exclusive products and experience. Perhaps HMV should have got behind indie music in the UK – becoming a record label. A CD Baby of the high street. Experiences could have been created by bringing live music into store. Alternatively experiences could have been created by helping customers find new music with in-store experts, DJs and a social network.

Consider it my opinion, but for retailers to survive they need to understand why they’re relevant and then innovate to get there. It’s risky but not as risky as doing nothing.

dilbert-skewers-microsoft

Further reading

Photo Credit: Beverly & Pack via Compfight cc

5 marketing lessons from Warren Buffett

Warren-B

1. A truly great business must have an enduring “moat” that protects excellent returns on invested capital

Product/service design, communications and strategy should build a moat for your business. By definition a moat offers protection in the form of a competence that is unique, difficult to copy and gives you competitive advantage.

2. In line with Berkshire’s owner-orientation, most of our directors have a major portion of their net worth invested in the company. We eat our own cooking.

Do you eat your own cooking? Do you send out the type of communications that you would bin or read? What about your agencies, do they practice what they preach?

3. [W]e try to stick with businesses we believe we understand. That means they must be relatively simple and stable in character.

KISS – Keep it simple stupid. Don’t try and bedazzle and confuse your customers. Make your services and marketing easy to use, comprehend and buy.

4. Never trade reputation for money.

Bribing customers is a sign of lazy marketing. Sure it works for a while but offering 20% cash-back is just another race to the bottom. Tribes are built through trust and interest, not bribery.

5. A reputation creates a consumer franchise that allows the value of the product to the purchaser, rather than its production cost, to be the major determinant of selling price

True marketing isn’t just about push and pull triggers, it’s about values and communication at a H2H (human to human level). The best marketers build and market exceptional products that customers value – it’s what Apple have done so well.

If you’re interested in Warren Buffett I highly recommend the Intelligent Investor which Buffett both approves on and contributed to.

Key marketing budget and b2b marketing insights

Singapore HDR by lipjin
  • Digital marketing is key growth area with 68% of businesses planning on increasing their digital spend
  • 79% of these companies will increase the spend on digital marketing by 10%
  • Digital activities account for 36% of marketing budgets
  • Shortage of digital marketing staff is preventing organisations from harnessing digital
  • Mobile is at a tipping point
  • For B2B marketers – trader shows/conferences, print advertising and telemarketing are top 3 activities. Search marketing is the first digital activity and is 4th
  • The top digital activities are search marketing, website, and then email
  • Search marketing and webcasts are the most engaging forms of B2B marketing
  • Online Forums are being neglected but could offer valuable engagement with buyers

Key Forrester recommendations

  1. Do less campaigning, more marketing – Free up time for new emerging technologies
  2. Double marketing content output – Produce long-format content for specific sectors and locations
  3. Increase labour allocations in social budgets – Recruit journalists and writers to develop your social presence
  4. Focus on budget returns – Squeeze more out of conservative budgets through lead nurturing, customer data management, asset management and faster reporting
  5. Invest in customer relationships – Develop customer advocacy for your firm through work of mouth marketing

Full Forrester report

Full eConsultancy report

Omnichannel Retailing for Digital Marketers

omnichannel-retailing

Explaining the What, Where, When, Who and Why of Omnichannel

Ecommerce. M-commerce. F-commerce. Social-commerce. Every letter imaginable has been dropped in front of commerce to define a new digital channel that customers can interact and transact with.

Demonstrating the way in which digital marketing is maturing there’s a new buzz word on the consultants’ lips – Omnichannel. Retailers who used to obsess over sales per square foot need to wake up to the fact that their entire operation needs to be available 24×7 via any means the customer has. Troubles at Blacks, Barratts, Woolworths and HMV are a strong warning to retailers that unless they radically rethink the way that customers interact with them; they’re dead.

In this feature I’m going to discuss what Omnichannel means for Digital Marketers and how we can drive forward the idea and strategy in our organisations.

Defining Omnichannel

Omni comes from the latin for all or every. Channel refers to the method in which customers interact with an organisation. Literally it is “every-channel”.

Omnichannel is the mix of all physical and digital channels to create an innovative and unified customer experience. Transacting through these channels is a hygiene factor. If all store staff do is scan products and collect payment then they are adding no value at all. As we’re seeing at the major supermarkets they can be replaced with touchscreen terminals connected to chip and pin devices. The experience is what creates brand equity with customers.

Whilst major UK retailers do have a physical and digital presence, they struggle to be unified and innovative in the way they serve the customer on these channels. They also fail to create brand experiences.

Diagram explaining what Omnichannel retain is

My children provide an excellent example of this. My daughter loves to go to the Disney Store and Early Learning Centre. Why? Well its certainly not to transact with them (that’s my job). It’s for the experience. She can run around, try out toys, do some colouring.

It’s the same reason I will always pop my head into the Apple store to try out their latest products or get some support. The store leaves me feeling that I’ve had an experience. Most other electrical stores leave me feeling frustrated.

Digital marketer’s have a part to play in this. Could you create an iPad version of your website for staff to use in store. It doesn’t need to look sexy but would provide shop floor workers with the information they need to serve customers. Imagine staff in store being able to research customer reviews on a product, check stock levels, price match and if it’s not in the store, order it with free next day delivery. Supporting store staff is a further opportunity for digital marketers.

Furthermore capturing data on in-store activity can drive targeted and personalised email communications and “next best offers”.

Engaging customers across all digital channels will become a necessity throughout 2012. Organisations need to be active across web, mobile and social digital channels.

Experience to Transaction: Task focused channels

As its name implies Omnichannel requires the retailer to have a presence in all channels. New and old.

From mobile apps through to bricks and mortar outlets, each channel needs to build the overall experience. Market positioning and brand message combine across each channel to create a unified customer experience. Technology provides the backbone for the experience with Client Relationship Management, payment systems, marketing campaign management tools and IVRs working in unison.

Diagram showing the best use of different channels

Digital marketers need to understand how their channel responsibilities fit into the complete journey. Adidas and Nike have achieved this with their mobile apps. Rather than creating a store in app form, they’ve created running and training programs to support what their brand stands for. The other issue for mobile apps is that their purpose may differ from location to location. When the customer is in-store the app should support that experience (such as a shopping list, Mobile Wallet and e-receipts).

All of this rich data is a digital marketer’s biggest asset. Tying the in-store, mobile, social and web customer data into a single business intelligent system that drives next best offers and can orchestrate one-to-one experiences is a utopia that isn’t far away from being achieved.

Omnichannel challenges

Transforming a tired multi-channel retailer into an omnichannel organisation requires the business to face up to the following challenges:

Challenge 1 – Having the right vision, goals and ideas

Innovation is at the heart of Omnichannel. In the current market condition a retailer cannot wait to see what their competitors do before and then copy it. The high street is becoming a life and death battle for survival where only the fittest and most agile organisations can survive.

Those in the organisation who design the customer experience need to start with a blank sheet of paper and simply ask the question, what do our customers want and need from us? This then feeds in to the Omnichannel question of how do we deliver this across all channels? During this round of questions, be very aware of the need to be unique. Consider your market position and what your brand believes in. Think broader than pure commerce.

Challenge 2 – Leveraging technology to deliver your vision

Central, federated technology applications will be needed across the enterprise to create a unified customer experience. For example I called my bank on Friday to question a direct debit. I had to go through security questioning three times and explain my issue four times and still didn’t get the answer I needed. This is far from Omnichannel and shows a real lack of joined up experience services.

Diagram showing how systems work together to create a unified experience

ERP (Enterprise Resource Planning) II systems need to be capable of integrating with the web, mobile, social and store channels. I’d also suggest that third parties need to be tightly integrated with you at a technology and business level. One of the major complaints high street electrical retailers face is regarding delivery of goods to the home. Store staff offer promises of delivery times which inevitably require you to spend 5 hours sat in your home waiting. Wouldn’t it be better if the customer could be sent an email the day before confirming that the delivery will arrive and then be provided with a direct number to the driver to follow up.

I strongly feel that some organisations have been failed by technology and over engineered processes. IT vendors are selected by technology teams and processes are reengineered in the pursuit of efficiency not excellence. A larger question remains over whether an organisation can truly get all of the benefits they want from a single technology implementation hence my opening suggestion of multiple solutions integrated and federated to deliver the customer experience.

Challenge 3 – Redesigning the customer journey across all channels

Charles Tyrwhitt is a retailer that I engage with across channels. I wouldn’t yet describe them as being Omnichannel but they are certainly a good multi-channel brand.

I was originally made aware of them through a friend who recommended an offer they were promoting. He forwarded me the email with a voucher code and I purchased some goods. Now I receive their print catalogues and email which entices me back onto the website and into store. For example I feel comfortable buying a shirt online, I know my size and have a high level of confidence that it will be right. The store is perfect for when I need to try something on such as the overcoat I bought last year.

Sure there’s more they can do to engage with me but it’s a good example of how multiple touch points come together to build a loyal customer:

  • Word of mouth/social recommendation
  • Print catalogues
  • Easy to use website
  • Access to stores for larger purchases

Mapping these touch points to the most appropriate channels enables us digital marketers to create the right functionality. Once we know the primary purposes of a channel we can then optimise for that purpose.

Challenge 4 – Recruiting the right people

Disney World don’t have park attendants. They employ “cast members”. Their role is to serve the customer and create a memorable experience that will outlast the holiday. Apple have their instore Geniuses. Cute job titles are a reminder of the real purpose of customer facing staff.However as Peter R Scholtes put it in his seminal book The Leader’s Handbook – you can change the job title but it won’t change the outcome. The right systems, training and people are required to create the desired experience.

Digital marketing teams need to be filled with t-shaped individuals who have specialist digital marketing knowledge and a base of core business knowledge. This allows them to work with the rest of the business as they understand the wider opportunities and planning process.

Challenge 5 – Transforming your business at the right pace and time

Omnichannel isn’t something that a business can trifle with. It requires a commitment from the boardroom to the shop floor. Vision and purpose will be set at board level that ripples through the organisation as systems are changed, people retrained and stores redesigned.

Each change will take time and inevitably resistance will come from different quarters. As the old adage goes you eat an elephant one bite at a time. Similarly achieving Omnichannel requires steady progress. Rush into it and you may accelerate into error. Too slow and you may never achieve the ambition.

Challenge 6 – Redesigning physical operations

It was recently put to me that Omnichannel is just Multi-Channel done right. I don’t have an issue with that but I do think that in reality there is a distinction between the two. Omnichannel is making all channels work together. They are integrated. Multi-Channel is having a presence on most channels.

Of all channels it is the high street that is broken. The businesses that are failing live there and have done very well during good times. Stock the shelves, open the doors and the hoardes will come regardless of the experience. Now the customer wants more, they can complete a transaction online with more ease than in your store. Online competitors have much lower overheads and if the race is to the bottom, they will win.

To reassert its dominance, the high street needs to reinvent its purpose. Rather than providing a transactional space, it needs to be an experiential space. Allow customers to research through your digital channels and to experience in your physical channel. The transaction can happen wherever, the very definition of Omnichannel thinking.

Digital’s place is across the whole experience. From the first interaction with the brand on a Facebook page, through to the instore interaction where the customer’s online preferences are loaded onto a store assistant’s tablet to help the customer test the goods.

Conclusion: Digital marketers have an important omnichannel role to play

We have been the innovators and entrepreneurs. With stretched budgets and limited experience we’ve had to prove ourselves over and over again. As digital marketing reaches maturity it is time for us to step up and help shape our organisation’s future.

A gloomy picture has been painted for retailers. Some classic high street names have already fallen and some are on the brink. I firmly believe that those who get Omnichannel right in the coming year will survive and grow to new heights.

Download the PDF Guide

PH2PKTHE2J27

Market Planning Case Study: Formula 1 Autocentres

Garage by VOD Cars

I’m very critical of the marketing I see, but then every now and again I see something that makes me feel that an organisation just gets it.

F1 Autocentres sent me an email this week that stood out. It offers me a car service. Nothing spectacular – it’s what they do. The marketing stood out because of the way they’d planned to add value using existing assets.

Market planning involves mapping the market situation with your assets (or capabilities) to deliver value to the customer. McDonald showed this in the marketing map contained in his brilliant book Marketing Plans: How to Prepare Them, How to Use Them:

Powerpoint diagram showing a marketing map

The email led with information about the upcoming rise in petrol prices (the market situation). Empathy was then demonstrated … “running a car is becoming increasingly difficult and expensive during this time of recession”. Then came the service offering -  the Fuel Saver Service. So not only will my car get a check over and service (the hygiene factor), it’s a service could save me fuel (the value).

They’ve not needed to develop new services, retrain staff or invest in expensive infrasructure. They’ve taken what they do (servicing), understood the market (dark economic times) and added the value that the customer will appreciate (fuel saving).

You can view F1 Autocentre’s email at http://www.f1autocentres.co.uk/email/november2011/index.html. Tell me what you think in the comments!

Free Marketing Map Download

You can download the marketing map in powerpoint format here. All I ask is that you subscribe to the blog by email to stay updated on my future posts!

If you liked it, share it!